March 5, 2011, 3:30 p.m.
posted by psyche
Complexity: As Simple As Possible, but No Simpler
At the end of Chapter 1, we summarized the Unix philosophy as "Keep It Simple, Stupid!" Throughout the Design section, one of the continuing themes has been the importance of keeping designs and implementations as simple as possible. But what is "as simple as possible"? How do you tell?
We've held off on addressing this question until now because understanding simplicity is complicated. It needs some of the ideas we developed earlier in the Design section, especially in Chapter 4 and Chapter 11, as background.
The large questions in this chapter are central preoccupations of the Unix tradition, some of them motivating holy wars that have simmered for decades. This chapter starts from established Unix practice and vocabulary, then goes a bit further beyond it than we do in the rest of the book. We don't try to develop simple answers to these questions, because there aren't any—but we can hope that you will walk away with better conceptual tools for developing your own answers.